Changes between Initial Version and Version 1 of Ticket #1834, comment 20


Ignore:
Timestamp:
Mar 2, 2013, 12:27:17 PM (11 years ago)
Author:
wraitii

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • Ticket #1834, comment 20

    initial v1  
    44(what I mean by 'not generate properly' is both that they will simply do something dumb, or that the result will be so different from the expected biome that it's basically just a different map that should be used, to give the same result in better. Alpine Valleys, again, is basically a flat snow map with a sort of hill in the middle. Not what it should be.)
    55
    6 Now about the "types of maps" you discussed, FeXoR, I'm not sure what point you're trying to make. "Realistic" maps in 0 A.D. are fundamentally flawed because the maps are too small for really random distribution, and would be really unfair. I'm thinking unfairness should really not be allowed too much in random maps (to some extent, of course. But not too much).There are ways to ensure this: creating resources not too far from the player bases, creating some elements of symetry… Using the RM constraints properly to distribute resources semi-randomly. We should probably stray away from maps that could be completely unfair (ie one side has all the gold, the other all the silver). But this is also another problem than the one at hand here.
     6Now about the "types of maps" you discussed, FeXoR, I'm not sure what point you're trying to make. "Realistic" maps in 0 A.D. are fundamentally flawed because the maps are too small for really random distribution, and would be really unfair. I'm thinking unfairness should really not be allowed too much in random maps (to some extent, of course. But not too much).There are ways to ensure this: creating resources not too far from the player bases, creating some elements of symetry… Using the RM constraints properly to distribute resources semi-randomly. We should probably stray away from maps that could be completely unfair (ie one side has all the gold, the other all the silver). But this is also another problem than the one at hand here.[[BR]]
     7(basically, if a map is fair for the first 10/15 minutes, it's fair enough. Beyond that, free game).